#1 Publishers Weekly, New York Times and USA Today bestselling author RaeAnne Thayne finds inspiration in the beautiful northern Utah mountains where she lives with her family. Her books have won numerous honors, including seven RITA Award nominations from Romance Writers of America and a Career Achievement Award from RT Book Reviews magazine. RaeAnne loves to hear from readers and can be reached through her website at raeannethayne.com.

The holiday romance novel is a genre beloved for its warmth, hope, and happy endings. I’ve written nearly two dozen books set during the holiday season and I have come to love writing them almost as much as I love reading them. I find something deeply satisfying as a reader in setting aside the hustle and bustle for a few moments to relax into a life-affirming story about people working through their problems to find true love.

Behind the twinkling lights and freshly fallen snow, the most memorable Christmas romances delve deeper, crafting characters and stories that are as layered and intricate as they are enchanting. For writers seeking to move beyond the surface and write holiday love stories with true emotional resonance, weaving complexity and nuance is essential.

Whether your readers are curled up by the fire or dashing between holiday errands, they crave more than just mistletoe and meet-cutes. They want to believe in love that blossoms not in spite of, but in large part because of, the past heartbreaks and emotional wounds of your characters. Here are ten in-depth strategies for crafting Christmas romances that ring with authenticity and stay with readers long after the last page is turned.

1. Develop multifaceted characters

Every unforgettable romance begins with characters who feel real, who bear scars and struggles and dreams. To create protagonists who leap off the page, dig deeply into their back stories. Perhaps your heroine is haunted by a Christmas Eve several years ago when a family rift shattered her trust, or your hero is carrying the weight of a lost love. Allow those histories to shape their present. Their fears, their boundaries, the way they interpret holiday traditions. Write detailed character sketches, exploring formative experiences, past traumas, and subtle quirks. This emotional groundwork will give your story a solid, rich foundation.

2. Balance holiday cheer and holiday struggle

The magic of Christmas is most poignant when it shines through even when your characters are wrestling with real issues of loneliness, grief, estrangement. In my current holiday release, Snow Kissed, my heroine is single mother Holly Moore. For the first time ever, Holly has to share custody of her young daughter over the holiday season with her ex-husband, who walked away from both of them. She knows she will be spending Christmas Eve and Christmas morning without her child, something not unusual to anyone reader who has ever dealt with child custody issues. I tried to use the warmth of the season as both balm and foil for Holly’s conflicted feelings to show both her pain and loneliness as well as the joy she still finds in the holidays. Juxtaposing moments of celebration with intimate scenes of vulnerability will create a richer, more compelling narrative in your holiday romance novel.

3. Utilize the power of contrasts

The holiday season is a time of joy but also a time when personal struggles can feel most acute. Use this contrast to heighten emotional stakes. The glittering backdrop of Christmas lights and celebrations can make your characters’ pain more vivid. By letting the holiday’s brightness illuminate both hope and hardship, you can create an emotional chiaroscuro that lingers in the reader’s heart.

4. Craft authentic conflicts

Believable romances are born from authentic obstacles. Move beyond clichéd misunderstandings. Instead, let your characters’ internal and external conflicts arise naturally from who they are. Tether the story’s tension to issues readers can relate to. The push and pull between career and family, the hesitancy to love again after loss, or the fear of repeating past mistakes. When your characters’ struggles are rooted in reality, the resolution of their love story feels all the more genuine.

5. Intertwine past and present

The holidays have a unique way of conjuring both joyful and painful memories. Letting your characters revisit and confront their histories, perhaps triggered by a family recipe or a favorite Christmas song, adds depth and emotional layering. Use these moments not only to reveal secrets to the reader, but to propel character growth. Healing and love, after all, always require facing the past head-on.

6. Create layered supporting characters

No one falls in love in a vacuum, especially in a holiday romance novel. Secondary characters bring texture, humor, and complexity to your novel. Give your supporting cast stories of their own, even if those stories never show up on the page. The best friend may be quietly nursing a heartbreak, the eccentric aunt might have a strained relationship with her sister, a parent might be struggling with health issues. These threads, woven alongside the main romance, add realism and provide opportunities for richer emotional interplay. When side characters are more than mere plot devices, the world of your novel feels as alive and unpredictable as real life.

7. Address tough issues sensitively

Tackling serious themes like grief, financial hardship, or family estrangement within a holiday romance requires a gentle touch. Approach these issues with empathy, avoiding melodrama or oversimplification. Allow your characters moments of vulnerability and resilience. Show them making mistakes, seeking help, or finding strength in unexpected places. Let hope and healing unfold gradually, and balance heavier scenes with warmth and levity, whether through humor or small acts of kindness. By handling difficult topics thoughtfully, you can honor readers’ real-life experiences while still delivering the comfort and uplift they seek in holiday fiction. Keep in mind that many of your readers might be struggling with some of the same issues as your characters. Their problems likely will not be as easily remedied as the people we write about, but I know as a reader first (and always!) that when I’m devouring holiday books about characters overcoming their struggles, I find renewed hope that perhaps I can make it through my own.

8. Build realistic relationships

True love grows from genuine connection, not simply holiday serendipity. Give your protagonists time to earn each other’s trust. Let attraction simmer alongside uncertainty and tenderness. Show them supporting each other through struggles, learning from each other’s perspectives, and making sacrifices both large and small. Avoid love-at-first-sight clichés in favor of actions and conversations that reveal slowly deepening affection. When love triumphs in a story rife with obstacles, it feels not only magical but eminently possible.

9. Use holiday symbolism

Christmas is rich with traditions and symbols—mistletoe, ornaments, gingerbread houses, carols—that can serve as powerful metaphors for your characters’ journeys. A battered ornament might represent a fractured family, while the act of lighting a tree could signal a character’s willingness to embrace hope again. Integrate these elements thoughtfully, allowing them to echo and reinforce themes of healing, forgiveness, and the possibility of new beginnings. When holiday imagery is woven into the emotional arc, it lends your story resonance and cohesion.

10. Craft a satisfying resolution

While readers of romance expect a hopeful ending, real life rarely gives us neat bows. Honor the complexity of your characters by offering resolutions that feel earned — not just happily ever afters, but happy beginnings. Maybe a couple commits to working through their issues together, or a character reconciles with their past enough to embrace the present. Give space for lingering uncertainties, but ensure emotional payoffs are genuine and satisfying. The most moving Christmas romances leave readers believing not just in love, but in the possibility of joy after hardship.

A truly nuanced Christmas romance will resonate with your readers. By blending holiday warmth with honesty and emotional complexity, you invite readers into a world where real love feels as genuine and layered as the people who find it. In doing so, you honor both the traditions of the genre and the rich tapestry of human experience, offering comfort, hope, and genuine connection for all who read your stories.

Snow Kissed by RaeAnne Thayne

Single mother Holly loves Christmas, but this year she’s filled with dread because of the wedding in her ex’s family. Meanwhile, Ryan is stuck with his niece for Christmas when all he wants is to be free doing whatever he wants. To solve both of their holiday problems, the two make a deal to tell a white lie. Ryan will be Holly’s plus-one so she can save face in front of her ex, and in return she will give his niece a magical Christmas until Ryan’s sister returns. Could the lie perhaps turn into something true?

Buy the book now: Bookshop.org | Amazon | Barnes & Noble